Guides

Variant covers, printings and key issues

By The Comic Catalogue · Updated 1 November 2026 · 6 minute read

Two comics with the same title and issue number can be quite different objects. One may be a first printing and another a later reprint. One may carry the standard cover and another an artist’s special variant. Learning to tell them apart is a core skill for any collector, and it explains a lot of the price differences you will see.

Printings

When a comic sells out, the publisher may print more. The first run is the first printing, and later runs are second, third and so on, usually marked on the cover or in the small print inside, called the indicia. Later printings often have a different cover colour or a note such as Second Printing. Collectors usually prefer the first printing, and later printings are normally worth less unless they are especially rare or changed in a notable way.

Variant covers

A variant cover is an alternative cover for the same comic, with identical story pages inside. Publishers produce variants to give collectors different art to choose from and to encourage shops to order more. Some variants are available to everyone. Others are incentive variants, which a shop can only order after buying a certain number of ordinary copies, such as one variant for every 25 or 50 standard copies ordered. These are printed in small numbers and are usually the most valuable.

Other kinds include retailer exclusives, convention exclusives, virgin covers with no logo or text, and sketch covers with a plain cover for artists to draw on. Variants are identified by the cover art and often by a letter, so the standard edition may be called Cover A and the first variant Cover B.

Direct and newsstand editions

From the 1970s, publishers produced separate editions for sale in comic shops, called direct editions, and for general shops and newsagents, called newsstand editions. You can tell them apart by the barcode box: a newsstand copy has a barcode, while many direct copies show the publisher’s logo or artwork in that space. Because fewer newsstand copies survived in good condition, they can be scarcer and more valuable for some years.

Key issues

A key issue is one that matters for a reason, and the price follows. The most common reasons are a first appearance of a major character, an origin story, a death or a dramatic change of status, the first work of a famous creator, or the start of a long-running series. Key issues are traded and graded more than other comics, and their prices can rise sharply when a character appears in a film or show, although such rises are often short-lived.

Be careful with claims that an issue is key. Some are widely agreed, and others are marketing. Before paying a premium, look at a few completed sales, not only asking prices.

How to check what you have

Start with the title, the volume and the issue number, then look at the cover art and the barcode area, and read the indicia for printing information. Compare against a reliable database. The Comic Catalogue lets you scan a barcode or a cover to find the matching issue and shows known variants, so you can pick the one you actually have.

A note on prices

Prices change with demand. A comic is worth what someone will pay for it on a given day. Treat any value as a guide, and buy comics you would be happy to own even if the price drops.